top of page

Trump, Xi and Putin Just Split the World

23 hours ago
8 min read

Almost everyone is calling the Trump-Xi-Putin summit the new Yalta. They’re wrong, and they’re repeating a line that came from the Kremlin. This summit wasn’t about carving up a map. It signalled a new era in which great powers meet to set the rules and govern the globe, while everyone else is sidelined. Call it the Club of Three, or the C3. The West is now playing geopolitical musical chairs, Russia has won a seat as an equal, and Moscow’s choice of the word “Yalta” may reveal exactly what it wants next.


Expert Perspective: Analysis by Abishur Prakash ("Mr. Geopolitics"), one of the world's leading geopolitical speakers and author of six books, advising companies on the fractured world. Prakash delivers keynotes in Toronto, NYC, London, Dubai, Warsaw, and worldwide.


Full transcript: Abishur Prakash ("Mr. Geopolitics") on the Trump-Xi-Putin meeting in China


Almost everybody is referring to the recent summit between President Trump, President Xi, and President Putin as the new Yalta. This is wrong. This was not Yalta. This was about something far bigger than Yalta. And those using the Yalta expression, usually geopolitical experts who are trying to stay relevant, are actually repeating a line from the Kremlin, because the entire labeling of Yalta came from the Russian government in the run-up to this meeting.


This meeting was about something far bigger than reshaping or giving territory. This meeting at its core was about signaling to the world that a new era of great powers has begun. That great powers, like the US, like China, like Russia, and we will get to the Russian variable in a second, the Russian involvement in this, because I know a lot of you are going to say, well, Russia's not a great power. We'll get to that in a moment. That the great powers of the world will now meet, and they will meet to set the global rules. They will meet to solve the global problems. They will meet to govern the globe. And everybody else effectively gets sidelined. Everybody else that's not considered a great power, too bad.


Enter the C3


So this is the death of the G20. This is the death of the United Nations. And this is the start of what I'm calling the Club of Three, or C3. Three nations meeting to define and drive the world, to coexist, to make clear what each other's spheres of influence are. And to ensure some level of stability.


And if it is now a club of three, a club of great powers, it is likely to expand in the future. Starting with India. If this is a club of great powers of the 21st century, that has to include New Delhi. So this could quickly become the Club of Four, or C4. And that means if you're not a great power, you might not have a seat at the table anymore.


The West Sidelined


And that brings the focus to the second big shockwave, which is that the West has effectively been sidelined.


Western nations are moving in one direction, the United States is moving in another direction. Consider the president of the United States, sitting across the table with the president of Russia, whom America has sanctioned, whose forces America is helping Ukraine attack, who invaded Ukraine and is still fighting a war in Ukraine. The West, for the most part, still behind Ukraine against Russia.


Yet in the C3, there's dialogue between the U.S. and Russia. There's engagement between the US and Russia. There's ideation between the US and Russia.


So the West, mainly Europe and Canada, plus the wider Western sphere of Japan and South Korea, all of whom have been on the same page regarding the Russians since the 2022 war began, are now staring at an America reopening the door to Russia, retracting sanctions, buying Russian diesel, inviting Putin to the G20, shuttering Starlink to Ukraine. And now directly engaging with Russia, and not actively trying to solve the Ukraine war.


So suddenly the West is sidelined, not just because the rest of the West has no seat at the table. But also because by meeting with the Russians, the U.S. is telling the Russians, fight that war. Do what you want. That's not gonna change our relationship with you. Our relationship is A, not defined by that war anymore, and B, is far bigger than a war that you're fighting that doesn't really involve us, that we, at least in this administration, don't really care much about.


That's the new reality. And it means that in this fracturing world, in a world where the Club of Three now exists, likely to become the Club of Four, Club of Five, in such a world, everybody is now playing geopolitical musical chairs. Everybody is in a state of flux. Nobody knows what these three or four nations are going to discuss and agree to next. And who is going to be on the weaker side in the world? Who is going to suddenly fall flat onto the floor? Who is going to lose their place? This is geopolitical musical chairs in the 21st century in a world that's fracturing.


Russia's Seat at the Table


Now, the Russia question has to be discussed. Because there are two big realities to Russia's involvement in the C3.


Again, C3. I'm calling it that. The US, Russia and China have not called it that. That's how I'm referring to it. New language for a new world. But there are two realities to Russia's participation in the C3.


Number one is that Russia's economy is a fraction of America's, and extremely tiny compared to China's. Russia, which has no technological leadership compared to the US or China, Russia, which does not have a diversified economy compared to the US or China, Russia, that does not have the same level of population size compared to the US or China. Yet when great powers meet, the Russians have a seat at the table. The Russians are positioning themselves as equal to the U.S. and China.


So this was a huge victory for President Putin, for Russia, by sitting and standing next to these two leaders, Russians have made it clear they are on equal footing with Beijing and with Washington.


That's a huge shift from the past, specifically the West's entire narrative that Russia is isolated. Russia's economy is gonna collapse. Putin's days are numbered. That is a huge shift from that. The reality is now, the Russians are regaining their place and power in the world.


And of course, Russia's place and position can't just be wished away. Russia has a significant role in global energy markets, global commodity markets. Their shadow fleet is moving energy across the global economy. Their intelligence capabilities, their ability to arm nations. The fact that the Russians are building nuclear energy plants in Africa, arming African countries, their ability in terms of regime change and espionage, Russia is, in those respects, a great power.


But in terms of economic size and economic future, coupled with a serious demographic crisis that Russia faces, well, Russia is not in the same league. But now it is.


Why Moscow Chose "Yalta"


And the second reality has to do with the entire framing of Yalta. Remember what I said at the beginning of this video. The Yalta framing is framing from the Kremlin. That's what the Kremlin used to describe this meeting between the US, China, and Russia. And all of these other "experts," experts with quotation marks, using it don't even realize they're just repeating a Russian line. But the Russians, like the Chinese, seldom do things by accident. And this was a purposeful, calculated decision to use that language. And why would Russia want to purposefully use the language that this is like the new Yalta, that this is a Yalta style conference?


But consider what Yalta was. Yalta was a meeting in 1945 before World War II ended between the US, UK and Soviet Union, where the US and UK were trying to lobby the Soviet Union to help them defeat Imperial Japan, and to discuss how to get rid of Nazi Germany, and what the new map of Europe would look like post-war.


And remember, some of the Soviet demands, if you want us to help defeat Imperial Japan, we want those islands that Japan claims as its own. And the US and UK gave the Soviets those islands, still disputed by Japan to this day.


So, if that's what Yalta was, it was about carving up geography. It was about taking geography. It was about creating a new map. That may very well be why the Russians wanted this meeting and are using that language. That Russia may be entering this meeting with the objective of beginning the process of actively carving up the globe. And if the Russians do it, the door opens for the Chinese to do it, and the door opens for the Americans to do it. The door opens to whoever joins this club next.


So, the Yalta framing: a terrible decision by other geopolitical experts to use it. Not surprised. Again, they're trying to stay relevant. They don't know what else to do. Can't help them. But it's deliberate framing by the Russians to signal why they're meeting, what they want, what their objectives are.


So that is incredibly important: great powers may not just meet to discuss global challenges, to propose new agreements, new economic pipelines. They may very well meet to give each other the heads up, to get each other's approval, to take X land, take Y territory, take Z geography.


And each of those three countries has clear geographic gains. The Russians with Ukraine. The Chinese with Taiwan. The Americans, whether it's Panama Canal, Greenland, Canada, the Arctic. All three of these countries have clear geographical ambitions.


Everyone Else


So that is the reality of this meeting between Trump, Putin and Xi. That is the new understanding between great powers, why they should meet, what they get from meeting each other. And it's the new reality facing everybody else.


If you're not a great power, you don't really have a voice anymore. You don't really have a seat at the table anymore. And you can think that you do. And you can attempt to create your own table. But if those big powers aren't there, your ability to maneuver is pretty limited.


So that actually all goes to this discussion about middle powers. Whatever the hell that actually even means. I don't know what middle powers mean. I'm not a fan of that expression. But it goes to the entire idea that between great powers and emerging powers, there is a set of middle powers that have some sway in the world, especially if they band together, which they're not. Nobody's actually banding together in this middle power boat.


So a lot to digest, a lot to think about, and a bit of a paradigm shift, but an important paradigm shift to see things clearly.


So I hope today's note resonated with you. Leave your thoughts below on whether you think the Trump-Putin-Xi summit was a success or a failure. Don't forget to hit like and subscribe, and talk soon.



Book Abishur Prakash for Geopolitics Speaking & Podcasts


Events/Public Speaking: Want Abishur Prakash discussing geopolitics (and the future) at your next event? Click here.


Podcasts: Interested in bringing "Mr. Geopolitics" as a guest on your podcast to discuss the changing world? Book him here.


Join the Mr. Geopolitics community below!



Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page